On a phone, buyers review their order more often, so keep the review screen
A checkout redesign usually starts by cutting whatever stands between the shopper and the pay button. The review screen, where the shopper sees the whole order once more before paying, is an easy candidate. In the Netherlands that screen has a particular role. According to the Betaalvereniging, iDEAL accounts for 71% of online purchases. The shopper chooses iDEAL, selects their bank and is sent to their own banking environment, where the payment details are already filled in and the payment is confirmed with the bank’s own method, such as the banking app, a QR code or a card reader. A shopper who approves in the banking app on the same phone leaves your site to do so.
What the shopper approves at the bank is an amount and a recipient, not the contents of the order. Once they have tapped through, your order is out of sight, and a wrong house number or a delivery date that does not suit them can no longer be changed in the checkout. It turns into an email to customer service, a failed delivery or a return. For most Dutch orders, the screen before the hand-off is the shopper’s final chance to correct the order.
Mobile buyers reviewed and edited more often
There is also evidence that buyers use that chance. Bold Commerce, a company that builds checkouts, released its first Checkout Benchmark on 13 January 2022. Among its findings: mobile shoppers who went on to buy were 41% more likely to have reviewed or edited their checkout. That is a correlation, not proof that an edit button raises conversion. A shopper who intends to buy has more reason to check the address and the delivery option than one who is only looking at the total. But it does mean that the review is used more by the shoppers you are about to win, and a review that is hard to use puts its friction in front of your most committed buyers. Bold drew a similar conclusion: the checkout should let the shopper make changes right up to the purchase.
Read the benchmark with its limits in mind. It was based on 3 million checkout sessions across more than 80 retailers running Bold’s own checkout, recorded between 1 July and 30 September 2021, and the release does not say in which countries those retailers sell. Its headline figure was that 48% of shoppers who start the checkout leave before they pay, rising to 58% on mobile. The data is now about five years old and covers one vendor’s customers, so the exact figures say little about your shop today. The direction of the review finding is what carries over.
Most review steps make a correction expensive
Baymard Institute’s checkout benchmark of 344 ecommerce sites shows how often the review step works against the shopper. In 68% of the sites, a shopper who wants to change something at the review step is sent backwards through the checkout flow. Baymard’s usability testing found that problematic, and it reports two failure patterns at this step: some shoppers abandon because of its design and flow, and some review pages are mistaken for an order confirmation, so the shopper believes the order is placed and closes the page. In Baymard’s words, “nothing is final before users confirm the order”.
Layout plays a part on a small screen. Bold’s benchmark compared single-page and multi-page checkouts. Across all devices they were close to even, at 48.4% and 47.5% completion. On mobile, single-page scrolling checkouts completed at 41.6% against 44.7% for progressive multi-page checkouts. The release gives no significance test and does not say how the retailers came to use one layout or the other, so other differences between those shops may explain part of the gap. What the figures do remove is the assumption that one long page is automatically the faster route on a phone. A single page often puts the order summary several screens away from the pay button, so checking the order means scrolling back up. A step-by-step flow can end on one screen that shows everything at once.
That screen has a short list of jobs. It shows the items with their quantities, the delivery address, the delivery option with its expected date, the payment method chosen and the total including delivery, all close to the pay button. Each of those has its own edit link that changes the value on the spot and returns the shopper to the same screen, with everything else still filled in. The screen does not look like a confirmation: its heading says the order still needs to be placed, and the button says what happens next, with the amount in it.
Test the correction, not only the purchase
Take your phone and place an order as a guest. On the last screen before payment, change the delivery address and the quantity of one item. Count the taps, note whether you land back on the same screen, and check whether anything you entered has disappeared. If the edit sends you back to the start of the checkout, fix that before you work on anything else in the flow. Then split your checkout figures by device and measure two things separately: the share of started checkouts that reach the payment step, and the share of those that complete the payment. If mobile loses more shoppers before the payment step than desktop does, look at the review screen first.
Sources: businesswire.com, baymard.com, betaalvereniging.nl and ideal.nl





