The account step is a one-second decision, and the guest route has to win it

Between the cart and the address form most shops put a screen that asks the shopper who they are. Sign in, create an account, or continue without one. The shop sees a menu of options. The shopper sees a question they want to answer in a second, so they can get on with the purchase they have already decided to make. If the answer they are looking for is not the first thing they notice, some of them take the screen to mean that an account is required, and that belief costs orders even when it is false.

Baymard Institute put a figure on how common this is in an article published on 17 January 2023: 47% of the sites in its UX benchmark that allow guest checkout did not make it the most prominent option on this step. A later Baymard overview of checkout UX, published in November 2024 and updated in November 2025, reports 62% of sites. The two figures come from separate benchmark rounds and Baymard does not present them as a trend, so the numbers are not a trend line. Both point the same way: on roughly half or more of the leading sites Baymard reviews, the guest route exists and loses the glance.

The cost of that is easy to state. In a more recent Baymard survey of 1,026 US adults who had shopped online in the previous three months, 18% said they had abandoned an order because they did not want to create an account. On the account step, a shop that only looks as if it requires registration loses part of that group too.

Asking for an email first turns a choice into a login

The most damaging version of this screen offers no choice at all at first. It opens with an email field and a button, and only after the address is entered does the shop decide whether to show a password field or let the shopper through. From the shop’s side this is tidy. From the shopper’s side, typing an email address on a screen about accounts looks like the first step of registering, and in Baymard’s testing a small share of participants hesitated for exactly that reason.

The same design creates a second problem for people who already have an account. A shopper who registered years ago, and only wants to pay, types their address and is sent to a password they have forgotten. A reset at that moment means a trip to the inbox, a new password and a detour away from the purchase. Baymard warns that an interrupted reset leads to abandonment and advises letting these shoppers continue as guests. Its later overview adds that in testing, strict password rules could cause checkout abandonment of up to 19% among existing account holders who struggled to sign in. Put the guest choice on screen before any email field, and let an address that matches an account still go through as a guest.

The eye goes to the strongest button and the plainest word

A shopper on this screen does not read it top to bottom. They look for a cue that matches their intention. Two things decide whether the guest route supplies that cue. The first is the wording. A plain continue button, or one that invites the shopper to go on with their email address, tells someone who wants to avoid an account nothing about whether this is their route; a label that names the guest option does. In a Dutch shop that means the word gast on the button itself, not in a sentence underneath it. The second is weight. A guest option set as a text link, next to a filled sign-in button and a form, looks like a fallback, and shoppers treat it as one.

Order adds to both. If the sign-in form or a register button comes first, a shopper who acts on the first plausible option commits to that route before they reach the alternative. Baymard’s recommendation is to keep the step to two options, guest and sign in, put the guest option first and most prominent, and move account creation to the confirmation page after the order.

On a phone, the fold and the keyboard make the decision

A desktop screen has room for most of the account step. A phone shows a slice of it, and what sits below the fold does not exist for a shopper who does not scroll. In Baymard’s mobile testing, shoppers who stopped short of a guest option lower on the page took its absence as proof that an account was needed. Typing makes it worse. A shopper who taps into the sign-in field brings up a keyboard that covers the lower half of the screen, and in one app Baymard tested, that alone was enough to take the guest option out of sight. Closing the keyboard brought it back only to its original spot beneath the sign-in form, where it was no more noticeable than before.

The check takes five minutes. Open your account step on a small phone, logged out, and note what is visible without scrolling. Tap into the first field and note it again. Then take a desktop screenshot and test it against four points: the guest option names itself as guest, it is a button as strong as sign-in, it comes first, and it appears before any email field. Every point that fails is a change to copy, styling or order, and each one reaches every shopper who arrives without an account.

Sources: baymard.com and baymard.com

Related reading